Texas officials are reviewing an appeal of the Federal Emergency Management Agency’s (FEMA) denial of household assistance following July storms and flooding across Central and Southwest Texas. Gov. Greg Abbott’s office said it and the Texas Division of Emergency Management (TDEM) are examining the federal determination and appeal process.
Heavy storms and flooding swept across the Hill Country and South and Southwest Texas beginning July 12, killing at least three people in Kerr, Uvalde and Val Verde counties and prompting more than 500 rescues, according to state officials. Abbott’s initial request estimated approximately $489.7 million in response and recovery costs, including more than $450 million in projected debris removal expenses.
The federal government approved public assistance for emergency work and infrastructure repairs in 23 counties but denied it for eight others: Atascosa, Bexar, Blanco, Brewster, Comal, Medina, Terrell and Wilson. FEMA said infrastructure damage in those eight counties did not warrant their inclusion.
FEMA also denied individual assistance for all 30 counties requested and statewide hazard mitigation funding. Individual assistance helps eligible residents with temporary housing, emergency home repairs and other disaster-related expenses.
The agency concluded household impacts were insufficient to warrant assistance but provided no damage totals or detailed explanation in its Sept. 28 letter to Abbott. Texas has 30 days from the letter’s date to appeal with additional supporting information.
Texas has appealed federal disaster aid denials before. Following Winter Storm Uri in 2021, TDEM challenged the denial of additional public assistance for several counties. The state also appealed a public assistance denial following Tropical Storm Imelda in 2019.
Outcomes have varied: Texas successfully appealed for funding to rebuild roads, schools and other public facilities after the 2013 fertilizer plant explosion in West. An appeal seeking public assistance for 15 counties and statewide hazard mitigation funding following a December 2013 winter storm was denied.
While Texas considers its appeal, federal officials are weighing longer-term changes to disaster assistance programs and the structure of FEMA. In May, a presidential advisory council recommended giving states greater control over recovery funding, including replacing project-by-project federal reimbursements with upfront grants. Major changes to those programs would likely require congressional action.
The proposed overhaul seeks to address longstanding complaints about slow reimbursements, complex requirements and inconsistent administration of disaster assistance.
Abbott and TDEM Chief Nim Kidd served on the 12-member FEMA Review Council. Abbott endorsed its recommendations, with his office saying the reforms would make FEMA more responsive and improve Texas’ disaster response.
Under the proposed public assistance model, federal awards would be calculated using a formula incorporating disaster characteristics and affected population, rather than individual site damage assessments. States, tribes and territories would administer project funding. The council also recommended raising damage thresholds used to evaluate public assistance requests and linking federal cost shares to preparedness measures.
The National Association of Counties says upfront funding could give local governments greater speed and flexibility, addressing longstanding concerns about complicated requirements and slow reimbursements. It also cautions that counties could lose the federal project-by-project funding safety net and face limited recourse when actual recovery costs exceed initial awards. Smaller and rural counties could be particularly exposed if states cannot fill funding gaps.
The California State Association of Counties has highlighted questions about whether formulas can fairly account for different disasters, geography and local conditions. Its analysis says states could seek additional presidential assistance when recovery costs exceed the initial payment.
The council also proposed consolidating Individual Assistance into a single direct payment for qualifying survivors whose homes are uninhabitable. Its organizational recommendations include evaluating staffing levels and redistributing FEMA’s workforce beyond Washington to reduce administrative costs.
The council’s recommendations were opened for public comment and call for a phased transition over two to three years. According to the Congressional Research Service, some changes could proceed through executive action, while many changes to disaster grant programs would likely require congressional approval.
Photo by Dagoberta from Pixabay
This story is part of the weekly Texas Government Insider digital news publication. See more of the latest Texas government news here. For more national government news, check out Government Market News daily for new stories, insights and profiles from public sector professionals.